harmful words.

by Liz on 07.17

You may have noticed some hateful terms being thrown about the internet. “Bigot,” and “misogynist,” are among the tamer sort as yet another man makes yet another sexist joke. This joke cut deeper, though, because of its violent theme and pointed direction at a specific woman. Joking about rape is one thing. Wishing rape on someone is another.

I don’t need to get into WHY it’s not “offensive,” but wrong here. The wise and eloquent have pointed out that rape jokes encourage rapists, they re-victimize victims, and they defeat the purpose of comedy by furthering pain rather than using laughter to rise above it.

It’s a troubling situation, but not one with which I’m unfamiliar. I’ve said plenty of dumb, thoughtless stuff.

I’m really embarrassed to admit this, so reserve your judgment, if you will.  When I was younger I used the  word “retarded” very often. Everyone around me used that word to mean something stupid, annoying, or fouled up. So, I did too. I don’t know what caused a light switch, but eventually I realized that of course it was incredibly disrespectful to use that word in that way. Those parallels are nothing but harmful and hurtful. Even then, it took some time to break myself of the habit. I’d find myself groaning, “Ugh. So retarded,” over stupid things throughout the day, then my face would flush, and I’d stammer some correction. It took awhile to remove the word from daily use entirely. But, it wasn’t a matter of malice or hatred. It was a matter of thoughtlessness and eventually, habit. I had never really given any thought to the meaning of my words, to the power for harm that they had.

I used the word “gay” in the same way. “Gay” was derogatory- like retarded, it was for anything that I thought was annoying. At one point, I said, “That’s so gay,” and someone snapped, “Really? Gay? That’s what it is?” and rolled her eyes. But you know, that instance didn’t cause me to rethink the term or my usage. It didn’t make me step back and reconsider what I was saying. It made me think that girl was a bitch and that I didn’t really want to hang around with her any more. Much later, a friend quietly mentioned in passing that the term used that way was hurtful to her. THEN, then I thought, “Wow. I’m an idiot. That makes a lot of sense. I really shouldn’t use that word that way.” I wasn’t purposely trying to be offensive. I was just ignorant.

Ignorance. That’s what this is about.

As a result of last week’s situation, statistics about how common rape is, how painful and dehumanizing it is for the victim, and about triggering PTSD are at the forefront. These are all facts and findings that I’m all too familiar with because of my interest in women’s issues, my passion for defending the disenfranchised, and because of how many sexual abuse victims I’ve known, befriended, comforted and counseled (and I’ll assume you are too, for many the same reasons). I’m aware of the devastation of rape.

I think it’s safe to say that your typical person is not- and not by any fault of their own.

People are going to say things that are hurtful and harmful. It’s of course everyone’s responsibility to call out wrong when we see it, to let people know how their words impact others so they can reconsider what they say and how they say it. That’s all important. But how can we do it in a way that causes positive changes rather than derision? How can we bring about understanding without condemning those who maybe are hurting others only by fault of ignorance? By making sweeping generalizations, calling names and hurling insults, we only shut down the conversation. And this is very much a conversation that should continue.

Let’s recognize the wrong that others do, speak out against it, seek to put an end to it- but without chalking up any person to “lost.” Simply because someone says something terrible doesn’t make them a terrible person. Because others defend those terrible words doesn’t mean they’re terrible people, either. I think we can hate the action without hating the person, and give the benefit of the doubt that some folks just don’t know. It’s fine to give certain wrongdoings extra weight, but it’s not fair to determine the wrongdoer irredeemable. Even those who say stupid, thoughtless, hurtful things can learn and grow and change.

Trust me.

you may also like::

  1. homebound.
  2. sex and clothes and other things.
  3. having it all.

Your Comments | Add a Comment

Lauren Michelle says:
Jul 17, 2012 9:21 am

I used to say retarded and gay, and while I’ve scrapped saying the latter, I sometimes slip up and say the former still, although it’s something I’ve been trying to purge myself of completely. I will say, though, that I don’t consider retarded to necessarily be related to mental disability or illness. One of my cousin’s is mentally disabled and I don’t see him that way at all. But when I see someone making fun of others with those problems or acting in a way so stupid and senseless and disrespectful they, to me, are the true retarded ones, because of their blatant, uncaring ignorance. They’re not ignorant because they can’t help it, they’re ignorant because they choose to be that way, and refuse to see things differently. And maybe that sounds harsh, but if anyone deserves to be called retarded it’s people who act like that. With that being said, I still try not to use the word, because most people relate it to those with mental disabilities., and in the end, it’s still crude and disrespectful no matter who you’re referring to.

Reply

nikkiana says:
Jul 17, 2012 9:35 am

I think you bring up some excellent points here. It’s amazing what kind of change you can affect if you hold your tongue in that initial phase of anger (which is when you’re most likely to throw those insults) and speak from a more calm, thoughtful place. Working in an open source tech field, I’ve had to deal with a lot of situations where men have said things that were somehow insensitive, inappropriate or just plain wrong… and I can say from experience, taking someone aside and calmly explaining why it upset you is so much more effective than the instances where a emotionally charged publish shaming has occurred.

Reply

my honest answer says:
Jul 17, 2012 9:51 am

I think the point is that nobody ‘deserves to be called retarded’.

Because it shouldn’t be used an insult.

Liz speaks pure sense, as always. Let’s all try to be better.

Reply

Rachelle says:
Jul 17, 2012 1:17 pm

Thank you for brining this up! Admittedly I haven’t followed this story too closely but I really wonder (and doubt) if anyone has brought up *why* someone would think rape is funny. Genuinely, I’m interested in having that conversation. I find lots of things funny that are probably offensive to someone and I think I can explain at least partially why I think they’re funny. I would really like to know what angle these people see on it, because then I think we start that dialogue you’re talking about.

Reply

Sheryl says:
Jul 17, 2012 5:02 pm

That’s exactly what confuses me as well. I get making jokes that other people may find distasteful, just like i get the fact that my fiance finds videos of people getting hurt funny even though I think it’s awful, but I don’t get what could possibly be funny about forcing a sex act on a woman.

Reply

liz says:
Jul 17, 2012 7:06 pm

I think it might, in part, be a misunderstanding of the depth of pain that accompanies rape. We joke about stabbing somebody, you know? Other things that are serious and painful for the victim. If you’re unaware of the whole-scope trauma that rape involves, you might think it on the same level as stabbing or something.

Similar, but different, we’re also living in a cynical culture that finds humor in extremes. Like, when someone is slightly edging toward bossy, we call him Hitler. The same guys who joke about rape think it’s funny to joke about dead babies. I don’t find anything inherently funny about dead babies, and yet they’re the punchline of how many jokes? (honestly, totally don’t get that trend and I remember it from middle school) It’s this extension of of exaggeration and lackadaisical hyperbole. Nothing is serious! Extremes are edgy and funny!

Reply

Caitlin says:
Jul 17, 2012 6:01 pm

“By making sweeping generalizations, calling names and hurling insults, we only shut down the conversation.” –words to live by, Liz. Thanks.

Reply

Rachelle says:
Jul 17, 2012 8:24 pm

For real. Thanks Liz! You have definitely made me pull back from my immediate need to rant and yell about things by bringing this up with regards to a variety of issues.

Reply

Leave a Comment

Previous post:

Next post: